Worst episode?

[blackmoses]

[blackmoses]

One and two!

[captainofbeef]

Two is the worst. My rankings:
Episode 1-8
Episode 2-7
Episode III-9
Episode IV-10
Episode V- 10
Episode VI- 9

[kiddo]

One and two.

I rank them as well:

Ep. 1 **
Ep. 2 **
Ep. 3 **
Ep. 4 ****
Ep. 5 *****
Ep. 6 ***1/2

[blackmoses]

Episode 1 - 4/10
Episode 2 - 4/10
Episode 3 - 8/10
Episode 4 - 10/10
Episode 5 - 10/10
Episode 6 - 9/10

[PTAhole]

1- 8/10
2- 6/10
3- 9/10 (10 for pure enjoyment, however)
4- 10/10
5- 10/10
6- 10/10

[criterionmaster]

1- 2/10
2- 2/10
3- 8/10 (because of the experience I had while watching)
4- 9/10
5- 10/10
6- 8/10

If I hadn't grown up on these I probably wouldn't like them too much.

[PTAhole]

You make me sick.

[captainofbeef]

He makes me sick as well.

[kiddo]

Why? His ratings are much more appropiate than yours

[blackmoses]

Yes they are.

[PTAhole]

Because, the original Star Wars is definately a ten. It is one of the greatest of all time, and I don't care what people will say about me.

[lordofdance]

PHANTOM MENACE 2/10
ATTACK OF THE CLONES 5/10
REVENGE OF THE SITH 6/10
STAR WARS 9/10
EMPIRE STRIKES BACK 7/10
RETURN OF THE JEDI 4/10

Star Wars is the only one that I truly am entertained by from start to finish. I very nearly despise Phantom Menace. The Empire Strikes Back has its moments, but it doesn't all work for me. The rest of them are good for passing the time, but not much else.

[blackmoses]

criterionmaster said:

If I hadn't grown up on these I probably wouldn't like them too much.

Why not?

[criterionmaster]

blackmoses said:

criterionmaster said:

If I hadn't grown up on these I probably wouldn't like them too much.

Why not?

Well because they have become nostalgic for me since I grew up on the films, if I watched them for the first time I probably wouldn't connect with them and just find them to be not as interesting. And since now I know they basically ruined most of cinema that fact would probably add to my hate, but since I saw them before I knew that, and they were one of the movies I first saw, I like them. I probably wouldn't like them that much if I just saw them today.

[Clark Nova]

my order, from worst to best:

Attack of the Clones: 4.5/10
Phantom Menace: 5 or 5.5/10
Revenge of the Sith: 6.5 or 7/10
Return of the Jedi: 7/10
Empire Strikes Back: 9/10
A New Hope: 9.5/10

[dontdigonswine]

Episode 1- 4/10
Episode 2- 5/10
Episode 3- 5.5/10
Episode 4- 9.25/10
Episode 5- 9/10
Episode 6- 9/10

Episodes 1-3 have such boring dialogue! I watched them each once, and will never watch them again. Episodes 4-6 on the other hand, definitely demand rewatches. Very fun.

[PTAhole]

criterionmaster said:

blackmoses said:

Why not?

Well because they have become nostalgic for me since I grew up on the films, if I watched them for the first time I probably wouldn't connect with them and just find them to be not as interesting. And since now I know they basically ruined most of cinema that fact would probably add to my hate, but since I saw them before I knew that, and they were one of the movies I first saw, I like them. I probably wouldn't like them that much if I just saw them today.

To quote you, <barfs>

[criterionmaster]

For quoting me I *barf* on your grave.

[blackmoses]

Dan, you don't like Star Wars to try and show off. Like, you like to good of films to like Star Wars. You give it high grades just so you don't have to actually show you don't like the films, and use excuses like "I grew up with the films" and "they are nostalgic". When you actually don't like the films at all, on purpose. I am sure you think Empire is decent and fun, but that is it.

[criterionmaster]

blackmoses said:

Dan, you don't like Star Wars to try and show off. Like, you like to good of films to like Star Wars. You give it high grades just so you don't have to actually show you don't like the films, and use excuses like "I grew up with the films" and "they are nostalgic". When you actually don't like the films at all, on purpose. I am sure you think Empire is decent and fun, but that is it.

Haha. Okay first off, you are forgetting I am the man who showed you the films in a huge marathon for no reason other than so you could come and see episode three with me on my third watching. I chose to show you all the films, and there was no influence on that other than that I love the films and wanted you to be able to see episode three. I do like the films, 4 and 5 are masterpieces, and I can easily say that too. You are saying I am cool to not like the films AND saying I am cool to say I like the films, which is it? Neither. I do like the films; you act like you just randomly saw all the films and seem to forget it is ONLY because of me that you like the films at all, since you dismissed the whole series based on episode two before I came along. So don't give me that shit about not liking Star Wars, I AM Star Wars. You embarrass yourself having only seen the special edition versions, so don't try and say you are a bigger fan than me. Now spare me the embarrassment of crushing you when it comes to Star Wars, Mr. just saw Star Wars last year. LOL!

[blackmoses]

Yes, you did show me Star Wars. But that as two years before you saw the films you have now seen. You showing me the films has nothing to do with this. You used to love Star Wars. But that was then, this is now. I know you don't like the films that much and try to like them less. You wouldn't act the way you do toward the films if you truly cared for the films in any way. Like I said before, you act like you like to good of films to like Star Wars. Also what does it matter when I have seen the films? I don't care if I just saw them today. That doesn't change the film. You act like you are better that you have seen them when you are younger? But what does that matter? You are a disgrace to Star Wars. You don't even have any of the films in your top 100. You are a film snob. That is all you will ever be. And I know Tim and beed know that you look down upon Star Wars and also know you are a film snob. At least Tim should know you look down upon Star Wars. And they both know you are a snob.

[criterionmaster]

I can't read that, I will try to decipher it tomorrow.

[ie]

Well, I just watched Star Wars a couple days ago, and it really is a great movie. I'm not convinced it's the greatest movie ever, but I do feel it is one of the rare few to deserve the attention, the fame, the glory and the legacy that it has received.

And I don't say that as a Star Wars nerd either, because I'm not. I just went into it having a certain amount of respect for the series, but nothing in terms of rapid fanboyism, and I still thought it was good.

[PTAhole]

While your intentions are noble, I slightly disagree. Dan does like Star Wars, but he pretends not to (or to like it less), to seem better than everyone else. There are times when Dan and I will talk about Star Wars for hours, and when that happens, it shows his true opinion of it. However most of the time, when I mention it, he always acts like he doesn't like it, but I know he does. It's unfortunate that he feels he can't like say, a Bergman or Cassavettes film and Star Wars.

[blackmoses]

Yeah, that is what I meant. He trys to like the films less on purpose. And Dan, if you don't agree to what Tim said then I don't even care what you have to say.

[criterionmaster]

blackmoses said:

Yes, you did show me Star Wars. But that as two years before you saw the films you have now seen. You showing me the films has nothing to do with this. You used to love Star Wars. But that was then, this is now. I know you don't like the films that much and try to like them less. You wouldn't act the way you do toward the films if you truly cared for the films in any way. Like I said before, you act like you like to good of films to like Star Wars. Also what does it matter when I have seen the films? I don't care if I just saw them today. That doesn't change the film. You act like you are better that you have seen them when you are younger? But what does that matter? You are a disgrace to Star Wars. You don't even have any of the films in your top 100. You are a film snob. That is all you will ever be. And I know Tim and beed know that you look down upon Star Wars and also know you are a film snob. At least Tim should know you look down upon Star Wars. And they both know you are a snob.

I had seen fantastic films then, maybe not as many but still tons. Okay, it has nothing to do with this? Nice try. Me showing you the films because I CHOSE TO is one of the things that shows you I obviously like Star Wars. How do I act towards the films? Do I not talk about them for hours? If I say I don't like the films, or act like they suck it is because I do that with every film. I am being facetious when I say things like this. It matters because your puny bitch ass is trying to tell me I don't like something that you JUST saw, you don't know anything about Star Wars or what I like. It matters because I grew up with some fucking fantastic films that's why. Oh nice, a disgrace huh? Need I say again "Mr. Star Wars Suxxx but I have only seen a movie I didn't pay attention to and the only reason I think it sucXks is because dem are nerdy movies" Not having the films in my top 100 doesn't mean anything seeing as how I haven't even gotten through all the films I give tens yet, they will come. I am a film snob; there is nothing that says they can't like Star Wars. Please, don’t embarrass yourself anymore blackmoses. EDIT: Read what you say out loud next time you write it, took me a long time to read.

ptahole said:

While your intentions are noble, I slightly disagree. Dan does like Star Wars, but he pretends not to (or to like it less), to seem better than everyone else. There are times when Dan and I will talk about Star Wars for hours, and when that happens, it shows his true opinion of it. However most of the time, when I mention it, he always acts like he doesn't like it, but I know he does. It's unfortunate that he feels he can't like say, a Bergman or Cassavettes film and Star Wars.

Yeah, I do that with all films (pretend to like them less). Blackmoses couldn't even carry on a 2 minute long conversation about Star Wars, and he tries to tell me what I like and don't like? Nice try. I don't like to be told I like or don't like something.

[blackmoses]

No, you have not seen a single film that I am talking about when you showed me Star Wars.

Are you deaf? You likED Star Wars a lot when you first showed them to me. But you have changed since then.

You do not act the way you do toward every film. I don't think you are being too facetious.

I just saw it? I saw the films three years ago. And this matters how?

I don't recall saying I know something about Star Wars. But I guess I did according to you. So can you quote me saying that.

I know what you like. You like good movies and music (imo). You just pretend not to like Star Wars as much as you do (or like it less). As Tim already said.

Yes, I was used to think Star Wars is terrible. I new nothing about film then. I was just like every idiot. That is exactly what dumb people say about Star Wars.

The only problem with not having them in your top 100 is that; you had Star Wars in your top 20 and it dropped from your top 20 to above 100. That is a big drop.

Thank you for admitting that you are a film snob. It has nothing to do with you liking Star Wars.

"Please, don’t embarrass yourself anymore blackmoses. EDIT: Read what you say out loud next time you write it, took me a long time to read."
How am I embarrassing myself? Is their a reason you are even saying this? You say pointless things all the time when we are fighting. What do you not understand what I am saying? If you can talk to the people on Flixster, then you can talk to me fine. Again don't say pointless things that don't need to be said.


You do not do it with all films, like I said before. I can have a two minute long conversation about Star Wars. I know what you like and don't like. You like Star Wars you just like it less on purpose. I don't like to be told I am trying to be cool. But does that stop you? I think not.

[criterionmaster]

blackmoses said:

No, you have not seen a single film that I am talking about when you showed me Star Wars.

Are you deaf? You likED Star Wars a lot when you first showed them to me. But you have changed since then.

You do not act the way you do toward every film. I don't think you are being too facetious.

I just saw it? I saw the films three years ago. And this matters how?

I don't recall saying I know something about Star Wars. But I guess I did according to you. So can you quote me saying that.

I know what you like. You like good movies and music (imo). You just pretend not to like Star Wars as much as you do (or like it less). As Tim already said.

Yes, I was used to think Star Wars is terrible. I new nothing about film then. I was just like every idiot. That is exactly what dumb people say about Star Wars.

The only problem with not having them in your top 100 is that; you had Star Wars in your top 20 and it dropped from your top 20 to above 100. That is a big drop.

Thank you for admitting that you are a film snob. It has nothing to do with you liking Star Wars.

"Please, don’t embarrass yourself anymore blackmoses. EDIT: Read what you say out loud next time you write it, took me a long time to read."
How am I embarrassing myself? Is their a reason you are even saying this? You say pointless things all the time when we are fighting. What do you not understand what I am saying? If you can talk to the people on Flixster, then you can talk to me fine. Again don't say pointless things that don't need to be said.


You do not do it with all films, like I said before. I can have a two minute long conversation about Star Wars. I know what you like and don't like. You like Star Wars you just like it less on purpose. I don't like to be told I am trying to be cool. But does that stop you? I think not.

Arguing with you is like arguing with an inanimate carbon rod. You are arguing for no reason, do you think I like the films or not? I don't care whether you do or not, all I care is that you admit to me being the only reason you like the films.

I act that way towards a lot of films, and most of the time they involve ptahole getting mad or other things (Alien, T2, Star Wars, etc.). It matters because you are trying to tell me I don’t like films I literally have seen over 100 times. You said “You a disgrace to Star Wars” implying that you in some way know that I am a disgrace.

Yes, and as I have already said, yes, I do say Star Wars sucks a lot, that doesn’t mean I don’t like it. I am saying publicly how much I like it, and normally only say to you and ptahole that I dislike it, just to piss ptahole off.

It isn’t that big of a drop since I have seen well over 100 better films since then.

And I would like to know how that is pointless seeing as how I couldn’t read what you said, so I said make it more legible. This time was better but you still misspelled a bunch of stuff. And yes, you embarrass yourself by arguing with me.

I tell you what you are doing, you tell me things only because you have started arguing like me for some reason, always asking questions and telling me what I am doing, even though you couldn’t be more off. Talk about Star Wars with ptahole sometime for a lengthy amount of time. I still don’t understand what and why you are arguing with me, there seems to be no point. You think I like Star Wars a slight bit less than I actually like it, I don’t even care enough to argue that.

[kiddo]

Sorry if I sound like a jerk, but this discussion is so meaningless and repeating, I dont really know why I`ve read through this.